TV Talk: American Idol 2009....week 3 blog

Ok, I missed last week's live blog chance because we were not home so I am going to try again this week....interjecting my thoughts of course!

First up....

Von-not so much. I am disgusted that Randy and KB(aka Kara-use your imagination on what that stands for) praised this guy so much. He wasn't horrible like others we have seen but it was not idol worthy-it was like something I would watch in a casino or hotel. I was surprised even Simon liked him. I think they were watching something different than we were at home...

Taylor-Not really that bad but again it was nothng in spiring. It seemed old to me. For such a young girl I thought she would sing something a little more fun and memorable. She definately has chops but I just don't know that its enough to be the best.

*KB is talking and makes no sense-I swear she is worse than Paula has ever been-and I am glad Simon called her out just a little bit* I hate Kara.

Alex-singing Elton is risky. I think his personality will help him to be memorable but I am not sure he was wonderful. Seemed a little "karoke" to take from Simon. I thought he was better than the first guy but still not best singer but he was funny and memorable and entertaining.

Arianna-she has a very nice voice. the song seemed a little old and "high school musical" and kind of dreadful but she didn't really put a youthful spin on it. Song choice could be what gets her on this.

Ju'Not-I liked him best so far tonight. He has potential and made a song his own. I am hopeful for him. We would vote for him.

Kristen-Her voice was good (although I liked the purple in her hair better!)She has a good voice although there is something about her that I am not overly excited about but voice wise she did well.

Nathanial-he has style but its just not something I can get behind as the American Idol. He is not bad and I could definately see him on broadway but it just didn't do it for me tongiht.

Felicia-a little rough in spots but strong overall I felt. I worry about it being memorable. This week there is a lot of middle of the road-unlike some the other weeks that really stood out. But she was enjoyable.
(I still hate KB and when she talks....all I hear is blah blah blah)

Scott-I liked him. He has a good voice. I think he has a nitch of song types but I think he could go to the top 12....he is definately not the worst tonight and I think he was one of the better ones. Got my vote-I want to see him sing and play piano b/c that is when he is really good.

Kendall-I liked her. She had one of the few upbeat songs and I think it stood out against some of the others, especially the girls. It was entertaining. It wasn't a perfect song but it was more memorable than others I thought.

Jorge-I actually enjoyed his performance. He has a good voice. Again, doing Elton is risky but I thought he did well. Not sure how memorable he will be-there is a lot of middle ground tonight but he was good. He surprised me and I liked it.

Lil-it was good. she has a nice voice and it was shown tonight. She definately stood out from others tonight. I think we will see her again...

All in this night was not bad. There was a lot of decent but not great so its going to be interesting to see how tomorrow night goes. I am still pulling for Scott myself but we will see how it goes!!

But have I mentioned how much I still hate Kara? While she was not as bad tonight as past weeks (maybe someone clued her in to the fact she is annoying!) but I still think it was a poor show choice to add her as a judge....how can we get rid of her??